Moving Goalposts


A debate has been raging within the United Kingdom on how to deal with bovine tuberculosis in domestic cattle. Unfortunately wild badgers have been targeted as a potential source for this disease, resulting in a cull in two designated areas which has involved the shooting of badgers to reduce the local population by more than 70% in an attempt to demonstrate a lower incidence of Bovine TB in cattle.

Most responsible scientists with expertise in this subject are against the cull and believe that it will not work. There is also the issue of animal welfare, in what seems to so far be a pointless slaughter of wildlife, bearing in mind that there are other more effective control measures such as vaccinating badgers, or management of livestock on farms in order to prevent the spread of the disease.

And so the badger cull debacle turned into a farce this week with the publication of widely contradictory figures for badger populations within the designated cull zones, and also the announcement that the badger cull may be extended again due to the its failure to reduce population numbers sufficiently order to make the cull “effective”.

This is of course an absurd situation. The inconsistent figures published indicate that no one actually knows for sure how many badgers live in cull areas, or how many have been exterminated as part of this cull. One thing has become apparent though. The badger populations are far lower than previously estimated, and may collapse if the cull continues. The environment secretary, Owen Paterson, blames this on the badgers themselves for “moving the goalposts”, a surprising and slightly ludicrous statement which can be interpreted as an admission that these beautiful creatures are in fact more intelligent than our politicians.

But the most disturbing part of this situation is that due to the wasteful and inefficient way that the cull was carried out (free shooting badgers regardless of whether they are healthy or not – 6 out of every 7 killed have been found to be disease free) the instigators of this cull extension have reverted to the use of trapping badgers in cages before exterminating them.

A very simple question is raised in the mind of the discerning reader; If a badger is trapped, with all the expense, effort and organisation involved with that, why not then simply administer a vaccine and then let the creature free?

During this difficult time, it is more important than ever not to lose sight of the suffering and devastation caused by these non-sensical culls. I have attempted to record a glimpse of their terrible impact in the following poem:

At rest with cubs in warm family sett,
Torpor disturbed by sweet-scented net,
With full moon outside just cannot sleep,
No final goodbyes on this occasion to weep.

Easy finds follow simple neat trails,
Does not seem natural but instinct prevails,
Leads blind follower into rusty cell,
Trapped in baited heaven waiting death row hell.

Piercing pain in back of neck, falls upon broken head,
Eye stares up from coffin deck, watches moon turn bloody red,
Executioner’s shadow suffocates life’s last sight,
Distant scream informs newly orphaned of end to sorry plight!

11 thoughts on “Moving Goalposts

    • You and absolutely right! Scotland has now been declared TB free, there is no cull.
      The Welsh government has scrapped the cull in favor of vaccination, so it can be done; it just needs the political will.

  1. Death descends upon diseased cattle
    Innocents are left to fight the battle.
    It’s not from them they make a buck
    On pollie’s decisions rests their luck.
    A quick vaccine would spare their pain
    Stupid pollie would have more to gain.
    From listening to those who say they know
    How to save the lives of those who live below.

    • Amazing! Through your exquisite poetry you have completed what I had wanted to say on this subject! How did you know?
      I had planned to write a second part to this post, covering the aspects that you have touched on so well in your poem! You have done that for me! Thank you so much!
      An absolute delight and treasure!

  2. it would seem logical to capture, vaccinate and release these badgers but as usual, killing wins – then, after the slaughter and their numbers dwindle, we can list them as endangered. very informative and i like your wrap up poem.

    • Your observation is correct. Yet logic seems to have been bypassed on this particulr subject. And there is indeed a real risk that Badgers will be wiped out in the cull zones.
      The poem was designed to give the reader a view of the last moments of a Badgers life, from Sett, to trap, to painful extermination, and the aftermath of leaving the orphans behind. Badgers cannot speak to tell sad their story, but we, as writers and poets, can do it for them.

      • you are a great friend for the Badgers – hopefully your words can spark an animal group to step in and help too. ☺

  3. thos whole thing makes my heart ache. I’ve never seen a badger, I was content to know tehy trundled through their world – this whole cill thing makes me sick. What is wrong with the world???

  4. Pingback: #UK Cruel unscientific hypocrisy of the #BadgerCull #CoalitionGovernment | johndwmacdonald

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s